Last week the news reported the latest plans to protect the threatened Northern Spotted Owl. The spotted owl is famous in the Pacific Northwest because of the decades-long battle between conservationists and industry with respect to the scope and cost of the owl’s protection. The latest government report indicated that the population of spotted owls has dropped by 40% in the last 25 years, in spite of the government setting aside millions of acres to preserve its habitat, and greatly restricting the use of millions more acres of private and federal lands. Now it seems that the problem is the Barred Owl. The Barred Owl is simply moving into the protected territory and is a much more successful, albeit unprotected, owl. The Bard Owl has no special privileges, but seems to thrive wherever it goes. The Spotted Owl has received special treatment by way of habitat preservation, criminal penalties for harm of the owl, and millions and millions of dollars in preservation, yet it cannot survive in nature, even with these Herculean efforts. The latest government response is to announce an “open season” on the Barred Owl – yes, actually shooting lots and lots and lots of these owls – and further tinkering with forest management.
This sounds strangely like the economic policies we have observed over the last few years where the government has made its business to pick winners (“green” energy companies, pharmaceutical companies, Spotted Owls, GM, GE) at the expense of losers (coal, oil industries, non-GM carmakers, Barred Owls, everybody else) in the wild we know as “business”. The government gives its protection to the winners in the form of government loan guarantees, grants, easy regulatory approvals, seats at the grown-ups table when discussing industry policy, and outright beneficial legislation. The losers, in the meantime, are shut out from policy discussion, are faced with intense IRS scrutiny, regulatory hurdles, and vilification by the White House at every opportunity.
When the government picks winners in the wild or in business, it is interfering with natural and capitalistic survival forces. No creature or business can evolve better survival traits until their survival is actually threatened – ask any small business owner you know. Resources in nature or business are finite; we are all fighting for a spot at nature’s/banker’s table. The poor Spotted Owl will fail to evolve because we won’t allow it to. Similarly, coddled “green-energy”, or other favored companies will not evolve to become better financial survivors unless we shut off the spigot of state favoritism. Many have proven that the state spigot does not guarantee success: Solyndra, Beacon Power, Evergreen Energy, A123 Systems, Fisker Automotive, etc. If these were such great, innovative, successful companies, how come they couldn’t get private funding? How many healthy Barred Owls have had their tickets punched because they didn’t donate to the correct political cause?
At the end of the day, the Spotted Owls of the world cannot survive on their own in the wild, and the government response is to shoot great quantities of their competitors. The government has picked a winner, and won’t change its mind or methods, and now there are a select group of people cashing in on these picks. I’m not so sure that Spotted Owsl are all that threatened; I read about similar creatures in the news almost every day. Barred Owl brethren beware: you are firmly in the crosshairs.





